Luo L.S.与 Karlin I.V.之间的激烈争论

Posted by on 12/21/2011 in LBM理论 | 2 comments

在Lyon参加ICMMES-2011期间,我录制了Luo L.S.与 Karlin I.V.之间的激烈争论视频。争论源自于Luo等2011年发表在PRE上的一篇论文(见后附),问题集中在Luo的ELBM是否是Karlin的ELBM。Karlin并没有注册ICMMES-2011,就是为了在开会的第一天和Luo在辩论,以澄清Luo所验证的ELBM并非Karlin自己的ELBM。Luo的整个报告目的是澄清BGK,MRT和ELBM谁优谁劣。今天看来,争论不会就此结束。在Luo等的文章表之后,Karlin等对Luo等的文章提出强烈的反驳,并在PRE上发表了针对Luo等的文章的评论,以表明Luo等所执行ELBM并非Karlin等的所执行的ELBM。辩论的激烈程度不亚于Luo和Karlin在ICMMES-2011会场上的程度。当然,争论是需要的,只有在激烈的争论之下,才会对LBM的发展起到巨大的推动作用。我们暂不谈孰对孰错,就这种发生在大师身上的精神值得我们学习。为了使得LBM朋友能够重睹大师之间的辩论,我们将时频共享与此,以饷朋友。

  • Numerics of the lattice Boltzmann method: Effects of collision models on the lattice Boltzmann simulations, by Li-Shi Luo, Wei Liao, Xingwang Chen, Yan Peng and Wei Zhang, Physical Review E 83, 056710 (2011).
  • Comment on “Numerics of the lattice Boltzmann method: Effects of collision models on the lattice Boltzmann simulations” , I. V. Karlin, S. Succi, S. S. Chikatamarla,Phys. Rev. E 84, 068701 (2011).
    4,294 views

2 Comments

  1. Thanks for your info, I will be checking in..thanks

  2. Excellent read, I just passed this onto a friend who was doing a little research on that. And he just bought me lunch as I found it for him smile So let me rephrase that: Thanks for lunch!

Submit a Comment